Scrawl
Scrawl is an American indie rock band. The band were formed in Columbus, Ohio, in 1985 by guitarist and vocalist Marcy Mays, bassist and backing vocalist Sue Harshe and drummer Carolyn O'Leary, from the ashes of Mays' previous band Skull; they adopted their current name after playing their first show together. The band received consistent critical praise throughout their career but never gained wider commercial success or recognition, largely due to issues with the record labels they signed with. In 1987, Scrawl released its debut album Plus, Also Too, which earned the band a deal with Rough Trade Records. The band released two albums, He's Drunk (1988) and Smallmouth (1990), before parting ways with the label. O'Leary left the band in 1992 and was replaced by Dana Marshall, who made his recording debut on Velvet Hammer (1993). The band moved to the major label Elektra Records for two albums, Travel On, Rider (1996) and Nature Film (1998), which were both underpromoted. Although they have not released any new material since Nature Film, Scrawl have continued to tour with drummer Jovan Karcic, who joined in 2007.
Scrawl | |
|---|---|
 Scrawl in 1988 | |
| Background information | |
| Also known as | Skull (1985) |
| Origin | Columbus, Ohio, U.S. |
| Genres | |
| Years active |
|
| Labels |
|
| Members | Marcy Mays Sue Harshe Jovan Karcic |
| Past members | Carla Sanseri Carolyn O'Leary Dana Marshall |
Scrawl is an American indie rock band. The band were formed in Columbus, Ohio, in 1985 by guitarist and vocalist Marcy Mays, bassist and backing vocalist Sue Harshe and drummer Carolyn O'Leary, from the ashes of Mays' previous band Skull; they adopted their current name after playing their first show together. The band received consistent critical praise throughout their career but never gained wider commercial success or recognition, largely due to issues with the record labels they signed with.
In 1987, Scrawl released its debut album Plus, Also Too, which earned the band a deal with Rough Trade Records. The band released two albums, He's Drunk (1988) and Smallmouth (1990), before parting ways with the label. O'Leary left the band in 1992 and was replaced by Dana Marshall, who made his recording debut on Velvet Hammer (1993). The band moved to the major label Elektra Records for two albums, Travel On, Rider (1996) and Nature Film (1998), which were both underpromoted. Although they have not released any new material since Nature Film, Scrawl have continued to tour with drummer Jovan Karcic, who joined in 2007.
History
[edit]Formation and Rough Trade Records (1985–1990)
[edit]Guitarist and vocalist Marcy Mays met bassist and backing vocalist Sue Harshe in 1984 while Harshe was visiting her boyfriend in Athens, Ohio, and the two quickly became friends.[1][2] Both members had experience playing in hardcore bands; at the time of the meeting, Mays was in a band called Skull with bassist Jane Young and drummer Carla Sanseri, and Harshe in No Amerika! According to Harshe, they did not contribute to their bands' songwriting as they felt intimidated.[2] When Mays relocated to Columbus in early 1985, she and Harshe both agreed they would write songs and be "masters of [their] own domain".[1][3] Around this time, Skull were offered an opening slot for the Butthole Surfers by show promoter and School Kids and No Other Records owner Curt Scheiber.[4] Young was not interested, and Harshe subsequently joined the band as her replacement.[3] Before a show opening for the Meat Puppets in August 1985,[5] Skull changed its name to Scrawl and Sanseri was replaced by Carolyn O'Leary.[3][6] According to Harshe, the band chose Scrawl because they thought that Skull "sound[ed] too heavy metal", and because it rhymed with their former name.[3] The band developed a following,[7][8] and embarked on its first tour in 1986, performing in the cities of Lexington, Kentucky, Tallahassee and Jackson, Mississippi.[3] Mays said that Scrawl did not expect themselves to be long-lived, telling the Chicago Tribune in 1990; "Everything for the next nine months [after the Meat Puppets show] was, 'Let's just do one more gig'. We never thought we'd be together one more month."[9]
With support from their friends, Scrawl recorded their debut album Plus Also Too in September 1986,[10][5] for less than $500.[7] The album was released through Scheiber's No Other Records label in May 1987, to positive reviews and media response.[6][8] After Robert Christgau gave the album a favourable review in his "Consumer Guide" for The Village Voice,[11] Scrawl received offers from Homestead, Twin/Tone and Rough Trade Records.[12] Following a performance for all three labels at CBGB in New York City—which Mays later recalled as "one of the worst" the band played—Scrawl signed to Rough Trade in the spring of 1988.[13][14] The band then recorded their second album, He's Drunk, at Paisely Park Studios in Minneapolis.[15] Released in October 1988,[10][7] the album had sold 4,000 copies by 1990.[16] Following its release, Scrawl toured with Firehose;[8] they continued to tour the United States in support of the album until March 1989.[10] After a hiatus due to O'Leary breaking her arm, Scrawl recorded their third album Smallmouth with producer Gary Smith in November 1989.[5][10] After the album’s release in February 1990, Scrawl went on a month-long U.S. tour, followed by a four-week European tour in May of the same year.[10] In the fall of 1990,[6] Scrawl left Rough Trade following abortive negotiations with the label over their fourth album and the release of a four-song promotional extended play of covers recorded by Steve Albini.[17][8] The label declared bankruptcy shortly thereafter, taking the band's albums out of print;[6] they were forced to buy back their master tapes at public auction.[18][19][17]
Simple Machines and Velvet Hammer (1991–1995)
[edit]In January and April 1991, the band recorded an extended play with Steve Albini, Bloodsucker.[20] Released in October 1991 through Feel Good All Over Records,[5] the EP quickly sold out of its first pressing of 2,000 copies.[19] Although it suffered from poor distribution,[6] Bloodsucker received strong reviews,[8] and was ranked ninth on the 1991 Pazz & Jop poll for extended plays, tying with releases from Dinosaur Jr. and Prisonshake.[21] Around the time of its release, the band played shows with the Afghan Whigs and My Bloody Valentine.[8]
In May 1992, O'Leary left Scrawl.[8] The following month, the band released the 7" single "Misery (Someone Is Winning) / Just Plain Bad",[8] before embarking on the "Foxcore, My Ass" tour as an acoustic duo.[6] By the end of 1992, the band had recruited Dana Marshall as their new drummer and signed with Simple Machines Records and Southern Records (for the UK).[8] Harshe said that the band were no longer worried about working with men again as they felt they had become better songwriters and performers.[18] In January 1993, Scrawl worked with Albini again for the recording of Velvet Hammer,[8] which was released on November 8, 1993.[22] In the fall of 1994, the band embarked on a tour of Europe[23] and performed at the Reading Festival in the United Kingdom.[24]
Elektra Records (1996–1999)
[edit]In 1996,[1] Scrawl were signed to Elektra Records by A&R rep Terry Tolkin.[25] The band released its major label debut, Travel On Rider, in August 1996.[26] The band toured the Northeastern US in October [26] prior to a supporting tour with Wilco.[27] For their sixth album, Nature Film , Scrawl re-recorded six of their Rough Trade-era songs and a cover of Public Image Ltd's "Public Image", alongside six new songs.[28] Harshe said that the band wanted to re-record their old songs as they had changed and "become more fluid live" over the years, and because "the thought of giving [Elektra] 12 new songs seemed depressing to us" due to the label's lacklustre promotion of Travel On, Rider.[28] Mays later said that the band "were basically saying 'fuck em' by not giving [the label] anything new".[29] The album was released in May 1998 [30] and was supported by a tour supporting Mike Watt.[28][27] Six weeks after its release, Elektra informed Scrawl via fax that they had dropped the band from its roster. In response, Scrawl launched a mailing campaign with its supporters and more than 250 people on its mailing list to send a postcard to label head Sylvia Rhone, featuring a copy of the fax from Elektra on one side and the following message for a sender to tick off and sign on the other:[31]
Elektra has dropped Scrawl. I am: 1) Disgusted; 2) Relieved; 3) Out of the Closet; 4) Other
In a 1998 interview with CMJ New Music Report, Harshe said that they were not surprised about being dropped from Elektra due to the minimal support for both Travel On, Rider and Nature Film, claiming that the label "never sent out anything other than advance CDs" and that both releases had sold less copies than their independent albums, although she did not feel bitter towards them.[32] As of August 1998, the former had sold 2,115 copies, whilst the latter had sold only 956 copies.[32] David Martin of the Cleveland Scene associated Scrawl with the "Columbus Curse" of bands from the city that were "wooed, signed, and tossed aside like chew toys by major labels", including Royal Crescent Mob, the Toll and Watershed.[1] A planned tour of the west coast of the United States with the Spinanes, due to commence in October 1998,[32] was cancelled after Mays broke her collarbone, which also hindered the band's plans to work on new material.[28][33] The band resumed touring in 1999.[33]
Subsequent activities (2000–present)
[edit]On March 16, 2000, Scrawl performed their final show with Dana Marshall, who moved to Sweden shortly afterward.[34] In early 2001, Scrawl played a few shows as a duo, with Mays and Harshe handling keyboards in the absence of a drummer.[35][36][37] In 2007, Scrawl reunited to celebrate the 10th anniversary of the Little Brother club in Columbus, with Jovan Karcic, formerly the guitarist of fellow Columbus band Gaunt, joining as their new drummer.[38] That same year, Harshe formed a new band, Fort Shame.[39] The band has continued to tour and perform since then.
In a 2023 interview with Matter News, Mays shared that Scrawl had started creating new instrumentals together since the summer, with plans to eventually release a new album, though they have set no deadlines.[40]The band performed at the 2024 edition DromFest in Catskill, New York,[41][42][43] and at the 2025 edition, with Tsunami's Luther Gray filling in on drums.[44]
Musical style and influences
[edit]Scrawl have been described as indie rock[45][46] and post-punk.[1][47] The band's first two albums, Plus, Also, Too and He's Drunk, were described as indie pop.[46][6] Gregory McGovern of Hot Press described the band's style as "minimalist rock ‘n' roll".[18] The band's musical influences include Cheap Trick,[48][49] Paula Abdul,[49] Head East, Judas Priest,[48] the Meat Puppets,[9] the Roches and Wire.[50] In a 1995 interview with The Michigan Daily, Harshe highlighted Mays' background in country and western music and her own interest in 1970s pop music as elements she thought came through in the band's music.[51]
Reception and legacy
[edit]Will Hermes referred to Scrawl as "[o]ne of America's great unsung post-punk bands".[52] Though the band consistently received critical praise throughout their career,[53] they never gained wider commercial success or recognition, largely due to issues with the record labels they signed with.[1][54] Jill Hamilton of The Ann Arbor News remarked in 1994 that "It's not that people don't like Scrawl. They usually like the band quite a bit—if they ever get a chance to hear them."[54] Despite their limited success, Scrawl retained a passionate fanbase,[35][55] whom Mays would later credit with preventing them from breaking up in a 1999 interview with Chapel Hill News: "I've never thought about how much weight that carries, but it must be a lot. We wouldn't keep on playing if there weren't people to listen."[56]
Around the time of Velvet Hammer's release, journalists began to hail Scrawl as a precursor to the foxcore and riot grrrl movements.[54] Although the band did not identify with either[1][57] and were "deeply suspicious" of their associations with riot grrrl by a "trend-obsessed media"—as suggested by their 1992 "Foxcore, My Ass" tour—"many of the musicians involved in [the] movement openly acknowledged their debt to [Scrawl]'s late 80's recordings", according to Colin Larkin of The Encyclopedia of Popular Music.[8] Kathleen Hanna cited Scrawl as an influence on her music,[58] whilst Tsumani guitarist Jenny Toomey called them an "enormous influence on what we did and how we did it."[59]
Band members
[edit]|
Current line-up
|
Past members
|
Timeline
Discography
[edit]Studio albums
[edit]| Title | Album details |
|---|---|
| Plus, Also, Too |
|
| He's Drunk | |
| Smallmouth |
|
| Velvet Hammer |
|
| Travel On, Rider | |
| Nature Film |
|
Compilation albums
[edit]| Title | Split details |
|---|---|
| He's Drunk/Plus, Also, Too |
|
Extended plays
[edit]| Title | Split details |
|---|---|
| Bloodsucker |
|
Split releases
[edit]| Title | Split details |
|---|---|
| January / Working Holiday
(Scrawl and Versus) |
|
| I'm Going Out Of My Way / Breaker Breaker
(Stereolab and Scrawl) |
|
Singles
[edit]| Title | Year | Album |
|---|---|---|
| "Misery (Someone is Winning) / Just Plain Bad"[5] | 1992 | Non-album single |
| "Your Mother Wants to Know"[5] | 1993 | Velvet Hammer |
| "Good Under Pressure"[5][60] | 1995 | Travel On, Rider |
References
[edit]- ^ a b c d e f g Martin, David W. (February 25, 1999). "Reluctant Godmothers". Cleveland Scene. Retrieved October 3, 2024.
- ^ a b Hurachulla 2016, pp. 334–335.
- ^ a b c d e Hurachulla 2016, p. 335.
- ^ Hurachulla 2016, pp. 335–336.
- ^ a b c d e f g h Anon. (n.d.). "Scrawl". Simple Machines Records. Archived from the original on February 19, 2001. Retrieved November 28, 2024.
- ^ a b c d e f g Ankey, Jason (n.d.). "Scrawl Songs, Albums, Reviews, Bio & More". AllMusic. Archived from the original on February 11, 2025. Retrieved October 4, 2024.
- ^ a b c d MacInnis 1989.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Larkin 2006.
- ^ a b Helm 1990.
- ^ a b c d e f g Myers 1989.
- ^ Christgau, Robert (October 27, 1987). "Consumer Guide". The Village Voice. Retrieved February 19, 2025 – via robertchristgau.com.
- ^ Hurachulla 2016, p. 336.
- ^ Larkin 2006 reports the date of Scrawl's signing to Rough Trade as March 1988, whilst Myers 1989 reports it as May 1988.
- ^ DeVille, Chris (October 23, 2012). "Rewind: Marcy Mays of Scrawl". Columbus Alive. Archived from the original on May 19, 2022. Retrieved November 28, 2024.
We had 20 minutes, and I broke two strings. [...] we ended up getting a record deal with Rough Trade from that show. But it was horrible. It was the longest 20 minutes of my life.
- ^ Holley 1988.
- ^ Madam X 1990, p. 69.
- ^ a b c d Strong 1999.
- ^ a b c McGovern, Gerry (1993). "The Unforgettable 5". Hot Press. Retrieved December 2, 2024.
{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: deprecated archival service (link) - ^ a b Thompson 1993, p. 66.
- ^ Bloodsucker - Scrawl | Album | AllMusic, retrieved November 28, 2024
- ^ "Robert Christgau: Pazz & Jop 1991: Critics Poll". The Village Voice. March 2, 1992. Archived from the original on June 27, 2002. Retrieved November 28, 2024 – via robertchristgau.com.
- ^ a b Jennings 1993.
- ^ Carlson 1995, p. 8.
- ^ Simpson, Dave (September 3, 1994). "Reading Festival, Melody Maker Stage". Melody Maker. Archived from the original on February 12, 2025. Retrieved February 14, 2025 – via Rock's Back Pages.
- ^ Knopper, Steve (January 25, 2022). "Terry Tolkin, Who Championed Alt-Rock at Elektra, Dies at 62". Billboard. Retrieved October 4, 2024.
- ^ a b c Reece 1996.
- ^ a b Malsey 1998.
- ^ a b c d Rosenheim, David (1998). "An Interview with Scrawl's Sue Harshe". Inkblot Magazine. Archived from the original on April 13, 2001. Retrieved December 2, 2024.
- ^ 614NOW Staff (January 1, 2014). "Marcy Mays". 614Now. Archived from the original on February 9, 2025. Retrieved December 2, 2024.
{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link) - ^ a b Kellman, Andy (n.d.). "Nature Film - Scrawl | Album". AllMusic. Archived from the original on December 25, 2023. Retrieved December 1, 2024.
- ^ CMJ 1998, pp. 3, 67.
- ^ a b c CMJ 1998, p. 67.
- ^ a b Meyer, Bill (February 11, 1999). "Scrawl". Chicago Reader. Retrieved December 2, 2024.
- ^ Schieber 2000.
- ^ a b Niesel, Jeff (January 4, 2001). "Scrawl". Cleveland Scene. Archived from the original on January 23, 2025. Retrieved November 28, 2024.
- ^ "Scrawl". July 21, 2001. Archived from the original on July 21, 2001. Retrieved November 28, 2024.
{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link) - ^ "Scrawl". April 2, 2001. Archived from the original on April 2, 2001. Retrieved November 28, 2024.
{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link) - ^ Writer, Staff (February 28, 2007). "Scrawl to reunite". Columbus Monthly. Archived from the original on May 20, 2022. Retrieved October 4, 2024.
- ^ Joy, Kevin (November 15, 2012). "Meet the Band: Fort Shame". The Columbus Dispatch. Archived from the original on December 8, 2024. Retrieved February 14, 2025.
- ^ Downing, Andy (September 29, 2023). "Scrawl continues to keep the drama to a minimum". Matter News. Archived from the original on February 11, 2025. Retrieved November 28, 2024.
- ^ "DromFest '24 Will Host The First Cell And Poem Rocket Sets In Decades". Stereogum. June 14, 2024. Archived from the original on June 15, 2024. Retrieved February 14, 2025.
- ^ Hart, Ron (August 26, 2024). "DromFest '24 Has Coaxed '80s and '90s Bands to Come Out and Play". The Village Voice. Archived from the original on September 17, 2024. Retrieved February 14, 2025.
- ^ Snyder, Adam (August 28, 2024). "Homegrown independent music fest this weekend in Catskill". Hudson Valley One. Retrieved February 14, 2025.
- ^ Shanley, Mike (September 25, 2025). "Dromfest '25 - And What It Meant To Me: August 29-31, 2025". The Big Takeover. Archived from the original on September 26, 2025. Retrieved January 18, 2026.
- ^ DeVille, Chris (October 23, 2012). "Rewind: Marcy Mays of Scrawl". Columbus Monthly. Archived from the original on January 23, 2025. Retrieved October 4, 2024.
- ^ a b Robbins 1997.
- ^ "Columbus Trio Scrawl Returns to Cleveland | CoolCleveland". coolcleveland.com. Archived from the original on October 3, 2024. Retrieved February 14, 2025.
- ^ a b Lobinger & Ferris 1986.
- ^ a b Hainer 1992.
- ^ Petkovic, John (June 13, 2013). "Columbus trio Scrawl plays a rare show at Cleveland Heights' Grog Shop Saturday". Cleveland.com. Archived from the original on November 17, 2022. Retrieved December 6, 2024.
- ^ Carlson 1995, pp. 8–9.
- ^ Hermes, Will (May 15, 1998). "Nature Film". Entertainment Weekly. Archived from the original on September 22, 2021. Retrieved June 23, 2025.
- ^ Gamboa 1999.
- ^ a b c Hamilton 1994.
- ^ Puckett 1999.
- ^ Speck 1999.
- ^ McGovern, Gerry (1993). "The Unforgettable 5". Hot Press. Archived from the original on February 12, 2025. Retrieved December 2, 2024.
- ^ McDonnell 1999.
- ^ Gentry 2012.
- ^ Anderson 1995.
Bibliography
- Anderson, Lydia (July 10, 1995). "Singles" (PDF). CMJ New Music Report. Vol. 43, no. 4. CMJ Network, Inc. p. 18 – via worldradiohistory.com.
- Anon. (August 17, 1998). "Elektra Drops Scrawl, Band Strikes Back" (PDF). CMJ New Music Report. Vol. 55, no. 8. CMJ Network, Inc. pp. 3, 67 – via worldradiohistory.com.
- Carlson, Matt (January 13, 1995). "Scrawl's 'Velvet' crunch". The Michigan Daily. pp. 8–9.
- Gamboa, Glenn (February 25, 1999). "Scrawl Sees Writing on the Wall". The Akron Beacon-Journal. p. F2 – via newspapers.com.
- Gentry, Brandon (2012). "Tsunami, Deep End (Simple Machines, 1993)". Capitol Contingency: Post-Punk, Indie Rock, and Noise Pop in Washington, D.C., 1991-99. Garrett County Press. ISBN 9781891053740.
- Hainer, Cathy (May 19, 1992). "These hard-rocking women go for the 'grunge'". USA Today. p. 4D. ProQuest 306496659.
- Hamilton, Jill (January 21, 1994). "Scrawl's career crawls behind critical reputation". The Ann Arbor News. p. D4 – via newspapers.com.
- Helm, Mike (May 11, 1990). "Concert line: 2 bands with an Ohio connection at Cabaret Metro". Chicago Tribune. ProQuest 1466923962.
- Holley, Debbie (October 29, 1988). "Audio Track" (PDF). Billboard. Vol. 100, no. 44. p. 40 – via worldradiohistory.com.
- Hurachulla, George (2016). Going Underground: American Punk 1979-1989. pp. 334–336. ISBN 9781629631134 – via Internet Archive.
- Jennings, Dave (October 9, 1993). "Velvet Overground". Melody Maker. Vol. 69, no. 41. IPC. p. 29.
- Larkin, Colin (2006). "Scrawl". The Encyclopedia of Popular Music. Vol. 7. MUZE. p. 315. ISBN 978-0-19-531373-4 – via Internet Archive.
- Lobinger, John; Ferris, Fred (April 10, 1986). "Nowhere '85 showcases hometown funk talent". The Lantern (Oasis). p. 7 – via Ohio State University Library Archives.
- MacInnis, Craig (May 19, 1989). "Sound of Scrawl best deciphered on vinyl". Toronto Star. p. D15. ProQuest 435932115.
- Madam X (May 23, 1990). "The Girls Next Door". OutWeek. No. 47. pp. 69, 73.
- Malsey, Ed (May 15, 1998). "Another Chapter". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (Weekend Mag). p. 26.
- McDonnell, Evelyn (September 1999). "54: Bikini Kill Bikini Kill EP (Kill Rock Stars, 1992) | The 90 Greatest Albums of the '90s". Spin. Vol. 15, no. 9. p. 146.
- Myers, Melissa (October 5, 1989). "Scrawl ready to record the third album". The Lantern (Oasis). p. 8 – via Ohio State University Library Archives.
- Puckett, Jeffrey Lee (March 12, 1999). "Scrawl Power". The Courier-Journal. p. F18 – via newspapers.com.
- Reece, Doug (October 19, 1996). "Popular Uprisings: Roadwork". Billboard. Vol. 108, no. 42. p. 24.
- Robbins, Ira (1997). "Scrawl". The Trouser Press Guide to '90s Rock. Simon & Schuster. pp. 628–629. ISBN 978-0684814377 – via Internet Archive.
- Schieber, Curtis (March 18, 2000). "Solid Scrawl Celebrates Its Time Together". Columbus Dispatch. p. 4H. ProQuest 394401616.
- Speck, Chris (May 14, 1999). "Scrawl: Grit and Determination". Chapel Hill News. p. B4 – via newspapers.com.
- Strong, Martin C. (1999). "Scrawl". The Great Alternative & Indie Discography. Canongate Books Ltd. p. 544. ISBN 9780862419134 – via Internet Archive.
- Thompson, Ben (July 1993). "Sound Check". The Wire. No. 113. pp. 65–66. ISSN 0952-0686 – via Internet Archive.
Further reading
[edit]- Anon. (1989) [Published June 24, 2021]. Scrawl (Live on WNYU + Interview 1989) (Radio broadcast). WNYU-FM. Retrieved October 4, 2024 – via YouTube.
- DiFrangia, Diane (October 3, 1996). "Experience Paying Off: Columbus' Scrawl Enjoying Major-Label Success at Last". Cleveland Scene. Vol. 27, no. 40. p. 15. JSTOR community.32630365.
External links
[edit]| International | |
|---|---|
| National | |
| Artists | |
